KAREN LEA ARMSTRONG
  • Home
  • Previously Published Work
  • What I'm Reading
  • Deep Thoughts and Existential Dread
  • Contact

Deep thoughts & existential dread

Blog postings to get things out of my head

"Lifestyle medicine?"

10/6/2024

1 Comment

 
Have you heard of “lifestyle medicine,” which is apparently new? A definition online suggests “evidence-based, person-centred care,” of which the pillars are: 1) healthy eating 2) mental wellbeing 3) healthy relationships 4) physical activity 5) minimizing harmful substances and 6) restorative sleep. Doctors can do extra training to become “lifestyle physicians,” which bothers me quite a lot because…doesn’t this concept sound an awful lot like family medicine?
Doctors are considered pill pushers sometimes, yet we have been talking nonstop about lifestyle since, well, the beginning of time. I emphasize smoking cessation so much that patients have said things like “You finally harassed me enough to quit.” People know, or should know, about harmful substances like tobacco, alcohol, caffeine, and cannabis, yet continue to misuse them and suffer the consequences. Is addressing that problem something new?
      I've promoted exercise endlessly, since it is pretty much the answer to everything for health. The only thing that makes peoples’ eyes glaze over more than talking about potential downsides of their cannabis use is talking about their lack of exercise. “I’ll exercise when the weather’s nice,” people say, in a community where it’s winter 9 months of the year. It’s too cold/icy/snowy/hot/rainy/buggy. I tell them it will improve their pain, mood, sleep, falls, strength, and brainstorm easy ways to fit activity into their days. Is anybody listening?
      Doctors discuss diet frequently. Want to know about benefits and potential risks of plant-based, low-preservative, low carb, high protein, DASH, Mediterranean, low residue, keto, or reduced-calorie diets? Most family MDs pick up information about diet at conferences, courses or in journals; dietitians, present on most health care teams, spend their entire education learning about these things and are widely available. Finally, are people listening to the information about diet from “lifestyle physicians” any more than anyone else, in a climate of climbing costs for high quality food?
      In family medicine, conversations about mental health occur daily. The way it contributes to physical symptoms, ways in which to improve it. We encourage different branches of treatment, of which medication is only one (frequently requested, and sometimes necessary).
      Sleep is an incredibly common topic for family doctors. You cannot just tell someone, of course, to get more/better sleep, without gathering a lot of information and providing many tools. It’s a long conversation and requires life changes, which are difficult for people. Again, many say “I just want you to give me something to make me sleep.”
      What bugs me about “lifestyle medicine” is the idea that it is different from family medicine. If seeing a “lifestyle doctor” makes someone more likely to commit to healthy change, I’m all for it (although, why does the name matter so much?). I am decidedly NOT in favour if:
-It suggests that family physicians and pediatricians aren't practicing this way already
-It makes patients think that lifestyle has not been addressed within medicine until now
-It promotes nutraceuticals and supplements as essential components of a “healthy lifestyle”
-It leads to “gurus” who then charge money for advice and interventions that we are all qualified to do under OHIP—creating a two-tiered system
-It leads to “blaming the patient” if illness does occur; even those with excellent lifestyles can get ill or injured, for a large variety of reasons.
      There is no one-size-fits-all solution in medicine. The six pillars listed are almost always key to overall good health, and they are addressed regularly by most, if not all, physicians. I’d like everyone to understand that their family physician is someone with expertise in “lifestyle medicine.”
 
Source of definition: https://www.rcgp.org.uk › your-career › gp-extended-roles

1 Comment
Chris Nanson
11/6/2024 10:58:03 am

I totally agree that lifestyle medicine is and has been the role of family docs and public health nurses for decades!
Why does a new label get all the publicity?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Hi, I'm Karen. This space is a chance for me to get some of those notebook sessions out there:  Motherhood, medicine, writers and writing, the state of the world. Non-published, sometimes non-polished, just a chance to open a discussion. Let me know what you think!

    Archives

    June 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023

    Categories

    All
    Alice Munro
    Altruism
    Altruism2
    Art Vs Science
    Art Vs Sport
    Banana Bread
    Barbie Toys
    Being A Spy
    Being True To Yourself
    Cancer
    Caterpillars
    Celebrity
    Chivalry
    Christmas
    Cirque Du Soleil
    Cleaning House
    Cooperative Living
    Dandelions
    Dementia
    Dog People Vs Cat People
    Dogs
    Elder Care
    Emergency Plan
    Environmentalism
    Feminism
    Giving Back
    Global Warming
    Gold Star
    Happiness
    Heroism
    Imperfection
    Importance Of Art
    Insomnia
    Justice
    Lie Vs Mistake
    Lifestyle Medicine
    Manifesting
    Medicine Myths
    Menopause
    Minimalism
    Motherhood
    Nature
    Patriarchy
    Perfectionism
    Personality
    Pesticides
    Pets
    Planning For Fire
    Plastic Use
    Plotter Vs Pantser
    Psychology
    Remembrance Day
    Riz
    Selfishness
    Shopping Cart Return
    Snow
    Solar Eclipse
    State Of The World
    Teachers
    The Arts
    The Barbie Movie
    The Most Important Thing
    Travel
    TV Vs Reality
    Vegetarianism
    When Bad Things Happen
    Winter
    Witch Hunt
    Word Distinctions
    Word Of The Year
    Writing Styles

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Previously Published Work
  • What I'm Reading
  • Deep Thoughts and Existential Dread
  • Contact